IT’S ALL ABOUT ASKING THE RIGHT QUESTIONS

“Some people see things that are and ask, Why?
Some people dream of things that never were and ask, Why not?
Some people have to go to work and don’t have time for all that.”
George Carlin

“We’re going to need a bigger boat.”
Peter Benchley

 

I hope everybody enjoyed the 4th of July. Independence Day has always signified the beginning of the end of summer for me. Experience has taught me that the time spanning from July 4th to the start of school runs at a pace much faster than that of the time spanning from Memorial Day to Independence Day. I don’t know how that is possible, but it is one of those things that just is.

Next week, MNPS principal’s time will be spent in district meetings as part of what is being called Principal Launch week. (Principal Launch Week Final Agenda) A quick perusal of the agenda reveals that much of the time will be focused on the Inquiry Cycle. It’s a concept that Doctor Joseph introduced to MNPS. All indications are that current MNPS leadership is going to double down on its commitment to the practice. Going as far as to create a non-supervisory position for former EDSSI Karen Desouza-Gallman to support the Associate Superintendents – yes, Community Supes are now called Associate Supes – in implementing and adhering to Inquiry Cycle practice.

Some of you may be familiar with the term, while others are probably wondering what exactly is the Inquiry Cycle. According to the Harvard School of Education,

A TOOL TO SUPPORT DESIGNING, DOCUMENTING, ASSESSING,AND REFLECTING ON MAKER-CENTERED LEARNING EXPERIENCES

In researching the term, I come away with the impression that it’s another one of those common-sense actions that someone is making millions off of by dressing it up and making it look far more complex than it is. You can find all kinds of articles and images that make the concept as complex as you like, but essentially it consists of 4 steps: Asking a question – researching answer through the review local data – choose a course of action – review and reflect on outcomes.

For example, we COULD ask the question do principals have enough time to prepare for the start of school?

In reviewing the data we discover those in many of the high needs schools were just hired for their positions. EDDSI’s for individual principals were just assigned on Wednesday afternoon preceding the Independence Day holiday. AP’s are scheduled to report to buildings next week and many schools have new AP’s. Many principals are still in the process of hiring teachers. The district needs to make sure that all principals are operating under the same framework. There is also essential information that legally needs to be reviewed every year. School starts in less than a month.

The action chosen is to schedule a week of full principal meetings in order to force principals to focus on district initiatives.

My reflection would be that by forcing building leaders out of their building three weeks before school starts, the district is increasing the difficulty level of preparing schools for students. A better course of action might have been to assign and notify principals in regard to their direct supervisors a month ago. This would have facilitated a discussion about district needs and what principal needs rise to the level of district needs that could have impacted time requirements for the principal launch.

Perhaps this conclave could have been held at an earlier date or the schedule could have been more condensed allowing principals an opportunity to spend time with new APs. There is little differentiation in the agenda between principals of various experience levels. Perhaps scheduling could have reflected that experience level and attendance at every session not made mandatory.

That, in a nutshell, is the Inquiry Cycle. I must admit though, I kinda like the whole inquiry concept. Used correctly, it has the ability to lead to better decisions and create authentic learning communities. It also puts more decision-making powers in the hands of those doing the work instead of employing outside entities to come in and dictate how the work should be done. As long as the right questions are asked and reflection is a true reflection.

Here’s another example of how things could unfold under the utilization of the Inquiry Cycle.

This time our question is why do MNPS educators feel so underappreciated?

In reviewing our locally generated data we discover that the issue is voiced often in district conducted survey’s. Local principal’s and teachers are seldom included in policy discussions and when they are their input is often ignored. There is a tendency to speak at those in the trenches rather than a consistent effort of collaboration. As a result, district edicts are often at least modified but often ignored on the school level. Buy-in by all remains elusive.

The action chosen by district leadership is to have only executive leaders present information to principals in attendance at the principal launch.

My reflection would be that this is an opportunity lost. Surely at least one principal in MNPS is already utilizing Inquiry Cycles in an effective manner in their school and could share what it looks like in practice. Perhaps principals could have been paired with executive leadership to co-present on several, if not all subjects.

There are 5 days of sessions and I don’t see a single one that is rooted in input from teachers and students. In all of this, is there no place for perhaps MNEA to speak with principals about the challenges teachers are facing and the general frame of mind they are in – how similar or dissimilar are individual buildings to the general mindset of teachers. This is like running a restaurant without ever talking to the cooks and waiters.

This is where administrators continually show their hand on how much they actually value teachers. It’s a month from school and the district has at minimum 200 openings – that’s being generous. Its well documented that principals have a huge impact on teacher retention. Would a session on strategies successful principals have utilized to retain staff and attract new high-quality teachers not have value?

There is a session on creating a “data culture” but I don’t see one, despite several references to a “culture of care”, that directly addresses creating a culture where teachers and students flourish. How impactful would it be to have a bevy of students address principals about experiences that impacted them, both positively and negatively?

If we actively apply the principles of the Inquiry Cycle, the result will probably be the implementation of better actions. But only if we apply the process to all decision making. Including decisions just impacting adults. Otherwise, it’ll be just like the principles of Social and Emotional learning where we solely focus on student interactions.

We preach how students should conduct themselves when interacting with other students, or how teachers should act when interacting with students, but very little focus is given to how adults in the building, or across the district, interact with each other. I can think of numerous occasions over the past few years where a restorative circle consisting of just adults might not have been such a bad idea.

My one caveat on all of this, including SEL, is where is the line drawn between these individual initiatives and good teaching. I would argue that good teaching incorporates elements of both processes.

I suspect some of this grows out of the drive to convince people that anybody can teach if they are supplied the right processes. That’s a theory that I reject whole-heartedly. Teaching is not just a profession, it’s an art form. We do ourselves a disservice when we fail to recognize that. Let’s hope that’s not what this is.

QUICK HITS

There continue to be reverberations from last week’s announcement by Mayor Briley that he suddenly found $7.5 million dollars that could be used for teacher compensation. Many are concerned that the raise is temporary and that it will be rescinded next year. Per Mayor Briley the funding is recurring. The raise in January also is not contingent on who is Mayor. While there is always a possibility of promises not being met, every indication I’m getting is that the risk for that is low here.

Personally, I’m hoping that this is the crack that will open tourist and developer generated revenues to deeper scrutiny. I don’t believe that there was only $7.5 that could be accessed by the mayor’s office. It’s being reported that 343,000 people celebrated the 4th downtown. If each of those contributed $3 in taxes, not an unreasonable assumption, that’s over a million dollars. I continue to believe that the under closer scrutiny we’ll discover that either the deals in the past were worse than we ever realized, or there is more money somewhere.

Rumor on the street is that school board member Will Pinkston and Mayor Briley have broken up. The root of the issue seems to stem out of a belief by Pinkston that the Mayor’s Office and TNDOE are in cahoots to take over the White’s Creek cluster and charterize it. At this point, it’s impossible to tell if state action on the White’s Creek cluster is an actual threat or just a figment of Pinkston’s conspiracy addled brain.  We’ll keep digging and if you hear sad country songs emanating from the Mayor’s office, at least you’ll know why.

Does anybody know if the MNPS communications department is working this summer or not? At the very least they seem to have taken a temporary leave of absence. The latest snafu is the recent rollout of EDDSI assignments to principals. The information was treated as the equivalent to Russian state secrets until principals were individually notified the afternoon before the holiday, a time commonly known as the holiday news dump.

Either the communications department wasn’t consulted on a communications plan for unveiling this essential information or they designed a terrible plan. Things being communicated in the manner as they were, did not get principals essential information in a timely fashion, nor did it reinforce a perception of transparency. MNPS has to do better.

John Ray Clemmons picked up a new endorsement for Mayor this past week. Knoxville’s staunch defender of public education State House Representative Gloria Johnson has lent her voice to that of the chorus calling for Clemmons to become Nashville’s next mayor. I interpret the move as a means to show support from fellow state representatives for Clemmons’s aspirations. Johnson is extremely well respected in education circles and as a result, should help Clemmons.

Interesting story out of Memphis. A charter school, currently under the Achievement School District, will leave the ASD and continue under the oversight of Shelby County Schools. Citing costs and differing regulations, Freedom Preparatory Academy has indicated that they will move 2.5 miles down the road to a new building and come under the SCSD umbrella. But the ASD has plans as well. Per Chalkbeat TN,

“The building is an ASD school and the ASD will continue to operate a school there next year per our commitment to the community and students,” said Jennifer Johnson, a spokeswoman for the Tennessee Department of Education, in an email. “We have a plan in place regardless of what Freedom Prep elects to do.”

Not like this going to become a mess or anything. Read the whole story in Chalkbeat.

Here’s a story out of Indiana involving vouchers and recruitment incentives that you’ll want to read. Nothing good will come out of Tennessee’s new legislation.

MNPS’s continually talks about the importance of equity. Yet that definition seems to have limited scope. While it’s true that the number of black administrators has steadily grown under Joseph and now Battle, the number of Hispanic, Asian, and Muslim leaders have declined. By my count, there are 2 Hispanics in executive leadership roles, no Asians, and no Muslims that I know of.

The number of Hispanic students has grown over the last 4 years while the number of black students has dropped. If we are truly committed to equity it is essential that we put the same amount of effort into identifying Hispanic and Asian leaders and teachers as we do Black leaders and teachers. Otherwise, it’s not equity. It’s exchanging one majority for another.

John Cooper picked up an endorsement by the Nashville Neighborhood Defense Fund.

Anybody heard anything from the Blue Print for Childhood Early Childhood Access? In January, the United Way of Metropolitan Nashville was selected as the lead organization to manage the implementation of the “Blueprint for Early Childhood Success,” the first-of-its-kind citywide literacy plan to double the number of Nashville third-graders reading on grade level by 2025. I know that Board Member Christiane Buggs is still employed as a project manager but other than that I’ve heard nothing.

“The Blueprint is one of the most comprehensive literacy plans in the country, and I’m confident that United Way’s vision will bring it to life,” said Mayor David Briley. “I look forward to seeing how they accelerate progress on the plan in 2019.”

That’s something that Mayor Briley and I share. I can’t wait to see how they accelerate progress in 2019.

What about TNReady scores? Has anybody seen anything on them? After al,l it is the first week in July and therefore they are becoming increasingly irrelevant in the guiding of instruction. I know, I know…just saying.

If you truly care about literacy initiatives that seem to work, Andy Spears has an update on the states Read to Be Ready Camps and how they are endangered due to lack of funding. It’s just one more sad story related to recently enacted voucher legislation.

That’s it for today. Thank you for your support. Make sure you check out the Dad Gone Wild Facebook page, where we try to accentuate the positive. If you’ve got something you’d like me to highlight, send it on to Norinrad10@yahoo.com. Thanks for your support, and if you feel so inclined, please head over to Patreon and help a brother out. Thanks to this week’s newest donors. Don’t forget to answer this week’s poll questions. Have a great weekend, and we’ll see you on Monday.

 

 

 

 

2 thoughts

  1. So with Buggs working for an organization that does business with MNPS, how many board members now get paid from companies who have a contract with MNPS?

  2. Misinformation, Disinformation and no information is a consistent problem here in the “It” City. From Social Media to Church Socials it seems they serve the roles that once was filled by proper Journalists and a diverse media. When you have one news source (Channel 5) trying to cover the varying scandals du jour and in turn provide adequate and fair and balanced coverage on an issue they cannot wear both hats. As a result the same 5 people are “sources” and provide point and counterpoint. This in turn draws across the standard lines that divide this city – Money, Family legacy, Church and then Race. The only time they co-align is about Sports and hence why that dominates the single source of news in the area – The Tennessean.

    Now that is a rag best used to line the cat box but one has to at least peruse it to get any info of local import. It is usually buried, passed over and badly written but often in said articles are a morsel of truth; truth a dish best served cold with a side of sweet tea here and just as overtly sweet and sanctimonious as one must pray before taking a bite. And that is of course for forgiveness for the lie that will follow. A lie by omission or by obfuscation is still a lie. I literally had to explain that to a future Minister. Okay then

    The South is infamous for its tellers of stories and in turn you would think that even what is news would be be better written but then again for a region that does produce some amazing literary giants it shows they were outliers in a state that has barely pushed past the quarter mark for higher education. I met a man who informed me that he and his wife have no children and do not feel it is necessary to pay for public education as they do not use it. Then proceeded to tell me, a 20 year vet, that he learned all the skills he needed on the job and managed to have his own business, own property and have a good life. I see… he apparently learned basic 3 R’s through what – Osmosis? I doubt he knew what I was referring to when I made that comment so out came the passive aggressive response via patronizing fake sincerity. Thanks you insulted my profession dude did you not realize that? And there it goes here in the “It” City.

    And what is appalling is the level of ignorance while claiming native roots about said city to the transplant of three years who seems to know her way around the varying neighborhoods and communities that align this city of it. And I do it on the bus that soon is another fatality of the it designation. And when I speak of my observations and information I have attained through said journey’s I am assumed a liar or teller of stories or just nuts. As again when I spoke of the designation of my neighborhood We-Ho as an opportunity zone yet the joke is that the train switching station aligns the area and in turn stalls, stops, runs 24/7 without recourse. I look forward to NOT seeing commuters and visitors sit for hours along 4th Ave S on the way to the MLS Stadium which is circled by said trains crossing at Bransford, Nolensville and Craighshead. How do I know this I have actual film running four hours to prove it. So when I offer said film then again I am dismissed as crazy as everyone who lives in Nashville knows trains! You do then why did you not know this? And so it goes. No one knows anything unless it directly impacts and affects them. And that is the information bubble in which you live here.

    The funding for teachers came from Regions Bank taking their cut: Regions has agreed to a one-year waiver on the housing agency’s $62 million TIF loan for the Omni Hotel and Country Music Hall of Fame, according to NewsChannel 5, which first reported the deal. The station reports Regions has agreed to take a minimum payment next year.

    I found this on the NBJ buried at the bottom of their varying sourced and locked articles that include that over 50% of the financing and investments are from out of state which is a flag about what is going on here in the new “it” city and again note their source: Channel 5.

    So when you have a city with little to no information and even less access to current factual data (as in vetted, sourced news not PR releases) you have a city that is clueless. Add to this the lack of citizen participation aka VOTING and a State determined to keep citizens off their registries you have idiots like Glen Casada and the Seat Filler appointed to office.

    So TC when you write and report and tell facts are you called crazy? An Asshole? A crank? Don’t answer it is rhetorical, as you know what that means.

    Facts are for fools apparently and I am happily a fool. Three months and counting down and no I won’t let the door hit me on the way out. I was raised to leave a place better than I found it. Not.Happening. As I hear here with great frequency: Bless You’re Heart and Good Luck to you. Thanks I need neither.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.