“What else are you supposed to do on this earth but catch whatever comes to you, with all your fingers, until your fingers are broken?”
―
Today marks the last hours before Nashville schools empty out for a week. Thanksgiving is next Thursday, and the kids are ready to get to celebrating. Teachers are ready for a break, too. Considering everything they’ve been asked to carry this semester, I’d say they’ve earned it.
Hopefully, everybody gets some turkey, some sleep, and a little distance from the machinery of public education. The machinery will still be here when they return. So will the questions.
This month, faced with threats of a state takeover, MNPS appears to have decided that the best defense is a good offense. Administrators have been busy telling anybody who will listen that Nashville has earned a Level 5 growth rating for the fifth consecutive year.
That is a commendable accomplishment. It deserves recognition. It also deserves to be understood as one part of the picture, rather than the frame around the whole thing.
Growth Is Good. Achievement Still Matters.
Many educators view growth as a key indicator of school success. I understand why. A student who enters a classroom behind and makes substantial progress deserves recognition, as does the teacher helping make that progress possible.
But achievement matters, too. If students remain behind their peers, the practical value of that growth has limits. Progress needs to move students toward the opportunities they’ll need after graduation.
It’s kinda like Cam Ward and the Titans. Everybody can tell me he’s improving. I hope he is. But eventually, improvement has to translate into winning games. Otherwise, questions remain about whether the team will ever reach the ultimate goal.
You can celebrate a better third-down conversion rate. Season ticket holders are still going to ask about the scoreboard.
There are legitimate explanations for why MNPS students may perform differently from students in surrounding counties. Poverty matters. Access to resources matters. Language acquisition matters. So do stability, opportunity, and the conditions students carry into school every morning.
Those explanations should inform how we support students. They cannot become a permanent substitute for delivering results.
Nashville students will eventually compete for jobs, scholarships, and college admissions with students from those surrounding counties. A thoughtful explanation of the obstacles they faced won’t automatically close the gap.
Meanwhile, much of the legislative conversation emphasizes achievement. District leaders can speak their truth to power, but they also need to address the measures those holding power are using to make decisions.
And growth ratings can change dramatically. After four consecutive years at Level 5, Memphis-Shelby County Schools fell to Level 1. Chalkbeat reported that district officials confirmed the result this week.
That deserves scrutiny, too. A Level 1 designation does not mean students learned nothing. It means measured growth fell significantly below expectations. Memphis also had stronger results in some grades and subjects, which makes a single districtwide number an incomplete explanation.
According to Memphis-Shelby County Schools’ research director, 53 Tennessee districts received Level 1 growth ratings this year—the lowest rating, indicating students progressed significantly less than expected. That does not mean they learned nothing. Before pointing fingers at teachers, I’d like to know which grades and subjects drove those results, what changed from previous years, and why so many districts fell short of the state’s growth expectations.
I’m also cautious about claims that low achievement automatically makes strong growth easy, or that high achievement makes it impossible. Those relationships are more complicated than our political arguments allow.
My frustration is with how selectively adults use the numbers. Strong scores become evidence of leadership’s vision. Weak scores become evidence that teachers need to work harder.
Funny how that works.
If lawmakers revisit TVAAS and testing requirements, I’m ready for that conversation. I’d welcome less testing and a serious examination of whether the accountability system serves students. But replacing one slogan with another won’t answer the underlying questions.
Voucher Arguments Have Students Attached
Voucher talk continues to be on everybody’s lips. House Minority Leader John Ray Clemmons has supported repeal efforts, and the debate over ending or defunding these programs is certain to continue.
I understand the objections. Public dollars deserve public accountability. Families deserve accurate information. Taxpayers deserve to know who benefits, what schools provide, and whether the program produces results worth its cost.
Those are reasonable questions. They ought to be answered.
But there are children attached to the decisions already made. Tennessee’s Education Freedom Scholarship program expanded to approximately 35,000 awards for this school year. Those families have arranged their lives around a program the state created.
That number does not tell us how many children transferred from public schools, how many already attended private schools, or how many families could continue paying tuition without assistance. Those distinctions matter enormously.
They also make it irresponsible to assume every family would experience repeal the same way.
If lawmakers want to end the program, they should explain what happens to participating students. Is there a transition? Are current recipients protected temporarily? What happens when a family cannot finish the school year or afford the next one?
Repeal and defunding are policies with consequences. Families deserve specifics before becoming somebody else’s talking point.
Here’s the philosophical question I keep wrestling with: What happens when preserving a system and serving an individual child point in different directions?
We routinely ask families to remain patient while institutions improve. Sometimes that patience is rewarded. Sometimes a student runs out of school years before the promised improvement arrives.
Do we have the right to demand that sacrifice? Is offering the bare minimum enough when we know a child needs something different?
I don’t have a neat answer. I am suspicious of anybody who claims to have one without acknowledging the trade-offs.
Supporters should have to account for the money and results. Opponents should have to account for the children affected by their alternatives. Everybody should have to explain what their preferred policy means on a Tuesday morning for an actual family.
That’s a harder discussion than announcing that your side cares about children. It’s also a more useful one.
Bellamy Enters the Superintendent Pipeline
Congratulations are in order for MNPS Deputy Superintendent Mason Bellamy.
On November 19, the Council of the Great City Schools announced that Bellamy is one of ten administrators selected for the fifth cohort of the Michael Casserly Urban Executive Leadership Institute for Superintendents.
Programming begins in February 2027, with monthly sessions through October. Participants study board relations, academic performance, communications, operations, finances, and labor relations. They also receive mentoring and opportunities to shadow current and former superintendents.
The Council says 11 of its 37 graduates have held superintendent, acting-superintendent, or interim-superintendent positions in major urban systems. That tells us something about the participants’ careers. It doesn’t prove the institute caused those appointments.
I suspect Bellamy wouldn’t mind adding his name to that list.
Former Dallas superintendent Michael Hinojosa oversees the program. His history is worth knowing because mentoring carries assumptions about leadership, accountability, and how school systems should operate.
Hinojosa received the 2020 Green-Garner Urban Educator of the Year award, the same recognition recently bestowed on Adrienne Battle. His career includes real accomplishments and some very difficult chapters.
During his first Dallas tenure, from 2005 to 2011, the district credits him with graduation-rate improvement, specialty and early-college schools, and passage of a $1.35 billion bond program.
Then there’s the 2008 budget crisis.
His administration disclosed a $64 million shortfall for 2007–08, followed by a projected $84 million deficit for 2008–09. These are different fiscal-year figures. Contemporary reporting counted 375 teachers among those who lost their jobs. Hinojosa acknowledged failures in budgeting and financial controls.
That belongs in the biography alongside the awards. Teachers who lose their jobs experience leadership failures differently from the people collecting leadership honors.
Hinojosa left Dallas for Cobb County, Georgia, in 2011 and retired from that position in May 2014. Dallas brought him back as interim superintendent in June 2015 following Mike Miles’s resignation, then made the appointment permanent that October.
During his second tenure, he expanded early childhood education, dual-language instruction, early-college pathways, and career institutes. He also continued the district’s teacher evaluation and compensation initiative and its Accelerating Campus Excellence program.
There is experience there that an aspiring superintendent could learn from. The failures should be part of the curriculum, too.
As for Bellamy, I increasingly wonder whether he is being positioned for consideration whenever Battle eventually departs. That is my interpretation. This announcement establishes no succession decision, and Nashville’s school board remains responsible for selecting its superintendent.
Still, preparation for future leadership is a public-interest subject.
Who nominated Bellamy? Who recommended him? What experience or accomplishments formed the basis of his selection?
Who pays for participation, travel, and lodging? How much work time will it require? Will outside organizations contribute, and under what conditions?
What does MNPS expect to gain? Will there be a project, a presentation, or some other benefit the board and public can evaluate?
These are ordinary questions about a public employee’s professional development. The announcement doesn’t answer them. Asking should be ordinary, too.
LEAD Is Collecting Familiar Names
Another leadership move deserves attention: Franklin J. Willis, MNPS’s former director of visual and performing arts, has joined LEAD Public Schools.
His departure from MNPS caught my attention. On November 2, LEAD announced his hiring as its first vice president of visual and performing arts, a newly created position across the charter network.
Willis has a substantial record in arts education. His work includes founding the MNPS Elementary Music Festival and directing and executive-producing Every Student Known: The Creation of an Anthem. The documentary followed students writing and recording an original song and won a Midsouth Regional Emmy in February 2025.
He is also a three-time CMA Foundation Music Teacher of Excellence recipient and has taught at Vanderbilt’s Blair School of Music. Those credentials span his career; they shouldn’t all be treated as accomplishments originating during his tenure as district arts director.
LEAD says Willis will oversee arts strategy, program development, and expansion. The network describes a multiyear effort to improve facilities, develop community partnerships, and create student performance opportunities.
I’m interested in seeing what that looks like in classrooms. A new title can signal commitment. Students experience that commitment through teachers, instruments, supplies, rehearsal time, and opportunities to participate.
How many additional students will gain access? Which campuses get what programs? How much of the investment reaches instruction? Those are the measures worth following.
Willis joins an organization already employing several familiar Nashville names.
LEAD CEO Ricki Gibbs II previously worked in MNPS. Tony Majors, another former MNPS administrator, is the network’s chief operating officer. Majors retired from MNPS in 2020, served as LEAD Academy High School principal from 2021 to 2023, and was announced as COO in July 2023.
LEAD has also hired former MNPS human resources executive James Witty as chief HR officer.
There’s a fair amount of district experience gathering under that roof. Families should benefit from it, and the public should be able to see how.
I’d also like to know who now leads MNPS’s arts work and how the district plans to sustain the programs and relationships Willis helped build. Individual employees can move on. Students still need continuity.
That applies to both organizations. Leadership announcements ought to open a conversation about services, staffing, and student access, rather than close it with congratulations.
A Different Kind of Growth
At the last board meeting, former MNPS student Lillith Pipkin again brought her case to board members.
Readers may remember her account of finding a note referencing a gun in an Antioch High School bathroom and the expulsion that followed. She has repeatedly maintained her innocence and returned to public meetings seeking to be heard.
Her position remains that the evidence did not justify what happened to her. I have serious questions about the handling of her case. Those questions deserve a clear response through a process that allows the evidence to be examined fairly.
Student privacy rules can limit what officials discuss publicly. They don’t eliminate a district’s obligation to provide a meaningful review process or a family’s need to understand how a decision was reached.
There is another part of this story worth recognizing.
Over the past year, Pipkin has become a considerably stronger public speaker. The nervousness that once accompanied her appearances has given way to confidence. She stands before adults with authority over her education and speaks directly about what she believes happened.
That takes courage. Repeatedly returning when you feel unheard takes persistence. Learning to organize your argument, hold your ground, and insist on being treated seriously is growth worth celebrating.
I wish the circumstances producing it were different.
We spend enormous amounts of time discussing student voice. Here is a student using hers. Whatever one concludes about the underlying case, the adults responsible for the process should be able to demonstrate that they have listened and responded appropriately.
Public confidence depends on that. So does the credibility of all those assurances about knowing every child.
There’s a lesson here for every discussion above. Numbers travel easily. A five looks good on a graphic. A one fits neatly into an argument for intervention. A scholarship count becomes proof of demand. A leadership award becomes proof that somebody’s doing something right.
Students require more attention than that. Their experiences don’t fit conveniently into a district composite or a legislative speech. One child can be thriving in a system that is failing another. Both experiences are real, and neither disappears because the other is easier to market.
That’s why I keep coming back to the details. Which students? Which schools? What services? What happened after the announcement? Who is responsible when the promised benefit doesn’t arrive?
These questions can sound repetitive. So can the claims we’re expected to accept without asking them.
The public conversation improves when officials answer specifically and critics hold themselves to the same standard. If I get a number wrong, correct it. If an explanation changes the picture, provide it. If there’s evidence that complicates my argument, I want to see it.
What I don’t find persuasive is the idea that asking questions somehow diminishes everybody else’s hard work. Teachers answer questions about their performance constantly. Students take tests to demonstrate theirs. Families explain themselves at meetings, hearings, and conferences.
The people directing the system can participate in that same exercise.
Before the Break
Thanksgiving offers a chance to slow down, sit with people we care about, and remember that life is bigger than the next press release or board meeting.
I’m grateful for the teachers still showing up, the families still advocating, and the students still willing to speak. I’m grateful for readers who keep asking questions even when the answers are inconvenient.
Celebrating progress and demanding explanations can coexist. We can recognize a Level 5 rating and ask about achievement. We can debate vouchers and insist on protecting students from careless transitions. We can congratulate administrators and ask what the public receives from their opportunities.
Have some turkey. Get some rest. Enjoy the people around your table.
When school returns, the students will still need us paying attention.
Categories: Education
“What else are you supposed to do on this earth but catch whatever comes to you, with all your fingers, until your fingers are broken?”
Leave a Reply